NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil, Blendable Eyeshadow Stick & Eyeliner Pencil – Milk (White)
Rating: 4.3 / 5
List Price: $5.97
Summary
The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil in Milk (White) is a versatile jumbo eye pencil that works great as a base eyeshadow stick and eyeliner. It offers creamy, blendable color ideal for brightening and highlighting the eyes, making it perfect for both beginners and makeup pros. With a solid 4.3-star rating from over 81,000 reviews, it offers great value at under $6. However, some users may find it less long-lasting compared to higher-end pencils and may require touch-ups throughout the day. Overall, this jumbo eye pencil is a reliable and affordable choice for experimenting with eye looks or adding extra pop to your makeup routine.
Pros
- Affordable jumbo eye pencil that delivers creamy, blendable color.
- Double-duty use as an eyeshadow base and eyeliner pencil.
- Highly rated product with over 81,000 reviews backing its performance.
- Wide variety of colors available for versatile eye looks.
- Smooth application with minimal tugging on the delicate eye area.
Cons
- Color payoff may require building up for more intense looks.
- Not fully waterproof, so may smudge during the day on some skin types.
- Needs frequent sharpening due to the soft, creamy formula.
- May not last all day without primer or setting spray.
- Some users report slight dryness after prolonged wear.
In-Depth Review
Build Quality & Materials
This jumbo eye pencil features a sturdy plastic barrel that feels lightweight and easy to handle. Its white Milk shade offers an opaque, creamy finish that glides on smoothly without dragging, a key aspect for a jumbo eye pencil. The twist-up design is not included, so sharpening is required, which is standard for this type of pencil. The simple and straightforward packaging keeps the focus on the product’s quality and color payoff.
Features & Functions
In real-world use, this jumbo eye pencil performs well as both a base and a standalone liner. It blends effortlessly with fingers or brushes and provides a brightening effect on the eyes. While it offers good initial pigmentation, users should expect to touch up during longer wear, especially if you have oily lids. It holds up better when layered under powder eyeshadow or used with a primer, which helps intensify and prolong the color.
Ease of Use & Setup
The creamy texture of the jumbo eye pencil makes it comfortable to apply without pulling or irritating sensitive eye skin. Its smooth glide allows for quick, hassle-free application whether you’re in a rush or doing a detailed look. Because it blends so easily, you can avoid heavy layering, which helps keep the eye area feeling light and comfortable throughout wear.
Everyday Performance & Experience
This jumbo eye pencil offers good durability when stored properly, but due to its creamy consistency, it’s important to keep the tip protected to avoid drying out. Regular sharpening is necessary to maintain a fresh tip and optimal application experience. To extend its longevity, cap the pencil securely after use and avoid exposing it to excessive heat or moisture.
Value for Money & Things to Know
One notable feature of this jumbo eye pencil is its versatility, working well as an eyeshadow base to brighten and intensify other colors or as an eyeliner to create sharp, bold looks. Compared to other similar jumbo eye pencils, it offers competitive price to performance ratio. It’s especially suitable for experimenting with eye makeup techniques like cut creases or inner corner highlights, making it a staple in many makeup kits.
Who Is NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil, Blendable Eyeshadow Stick & Eyeliner Pencil – Milk (White) Best For?
The jumbo eye pencil is best used for quick and easy eye makeup applications like brightening the waterline or eyelid. It’s ideal for creating a clean, white base for other eyeshadows or for use as a standout liner color. Its creamy blendable formula is suited to those who want versatile, no-fuss eye looks without investing in multiple products.
Best For
- Best for people who want an affordable and multifunctional jumbo eye pencil.
- Ideal if you like quick eyeshadow base application and easy blending.
- Another good fit is makeup beginners needing an easy-to-use eyeliner pencil.
- Another good use case is for those who prefer creamy, blendable makeup sticks.
- Another clear ‘best for’ scenario is anyone looking to brighten or highlight their eyes.
Not Ideal For
- Not ideal for buyers who need long-lasting waterproof jumbo eye pencil.
- Avoid if you prefer twist-up pencils rather than those that require sharpening.
- Another situation where this is not suitable is if you want highly pigmented, intense color in one swipe.
- Another ‘not for’ scenario is if you have very oily eyelids needing smudge-proof formula.
- Another ‘avoid if’ scenario is sensitive eyes prone to dryness from creamy pencil formulas.
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil, Blendable Eyeshadow Stick & Eyeliner Pencil – Milk (White) – FAQ
Is this jumbo eye pencil good for sensitive eyes?
Many users with sensitive eyes find this jumbo eye pencil comfortable due to its creamy texture and smooth application. However, if you have very sensitive or allergy-prone skin, it’s wise to patch test first since the formula may cause dryness in some cases.
Can this jumbo eye pencil be used as a base for eyeshadow?
Yes, the jumbo eye pencil works very well as an eyeshadow base to brighten the eyelids and help other eyeshadows pop. Its creamy consistency makes blending easy, so it’s a popular choice for prepping the eyes before applying powder shadows.
How long does the NYX jumbo eye pencil last on the eyes?
On its own, the jumbo eye pencil lasts a few hours but may require touch-ups, especially on oily lids. Using an eyeshadow primer underneath or setting with powder helps improve longevity and reduce smudging throughout the day.